Of the $40.00 a customer pays at your website's checkout, between $1.46 and $2.46 never reaches your bank account, and three more charges can arrive weeks after the sale.
Short answer: on its standard US pricing, Stripe takes 2.9% + 30 cents from a payment by a US card, so a $40 order leaves you $38.54. Square takes the same on its paid plans and 3.3% + 30 cents on its free plan, which leaves $38.38. A card from abroad that also needs a currency conversion costs 5.4% + 30 cents on Stripe. After the sale, a refund does not give the fee back, and a card dispute costs $15 on Stripe even when you win it, and $30 when you fight it and lose.
One $40 order, counted out cent by cent
The same order paid four ways. Rates are the US list prices on Stripe's pricing page and Square's fees page, read on 2026-11-12. Every fee here has two parts: a percentage of the whole amount charged, and a fixed 30 cents per payment. A negotiated rate will differ.
-
Stripe 2.9% + 30¢
- Order total
- $40.00
- Percentage part
- - $1.16
- Fixed part
- - $0.30
- Fee
- $1.46
- You keep
- $38.54
3.65% of the order
A card issued in the US, typed in by the customer at your checkout. Credit, debit, prepaid and wallet payments all pay the same flat rate.
-
Square, Free plan 3.3% + 30¢
- Order total
- $40.00
- Percentage part
- - $1.32
- Fixed part
- - $0.30
- Fee
- $1.62
- You keep
- $38.38
4.05% of the order
The online rate for card payments taken through a Square online checkout or invoice with no monthly plan.
-
Square, Plus or Premium 2.9% + 30¢
- Order total
- $40.00
- Percentage part
- - $1.16
- Fixed part
- - $0.30
- Fee
- $1.46
- You keep
- $38.54
3.65% of the order
The same order on a paid plan. The plan price is billed monthly on top, so the lower rate pays off only above a certain volume (see drawer 5).
-
Stripe, card from abroad 5.4% + 30¢
- Order total
- $40.00
- Percentage part
- - $2.16
- Fixed part
- - $0.30
- Fee
- $2.46
- You keep
- $37.54
6.15% of the order
2.9% base, plus 1.5% for a card issued outside the US, plus 1% because the charge needed a currency conversion.
Why a $10 order gives up more than a $200 one
The 30 cents is the same on every payment, so it weighs most on small orders. On a $10 order it is half the whole fee.
If most of your orders are under $15, the fixed part is the line to work on, not the percentage.
Charges that turn up after the sale
None of these show on the day of the order. All of them come out of the same balance.
-
$1.46
A refund keeps the fee
Refund the $40 order in full and you send back $40.00, but Stripe's processing fees from the original transaction aren't returned. Square says the same: the processing fees for the payment are not refunded to you. A returned order costs you the fee plus the postage.
-
$0
A cancel costs nothing
Stripe lets you cancel a payment before it is completed at no cost, and a refund made shortly after the charge may go through as a reversal, on which Stripe withholds no fee. If you take payment when you ship, a cancelled order before that point is free.
-
$15
A dispute, even one you win
When a customer disputes a charge with their bank, Stripe debits the amount plus a dispute received fee. For US businesses it is $15, and Stripe never returns it unless your contract says otherwise.
-
+$15
Fighting the dispute
Counter it with evidence and a second $15 dispute countered fee applies. Stripe returns that one if you win. Fight a dispute over the $40 order and lose, and you are out $40 plus $30 in fees, with the goods gone.
-
+0.5%
A card number you type in
Take an order by phone and type the card into your dashboard, and Stripe adds 0.5% for a manually entered card: $1.66 on the $40 order instead of $1.46.
-
~$20
The early fraud warning line
Card networks sometimes flag a payment as likely fraud before any dispute. Stripe says about 40% of Visa and Mastercard warnings become fraud disputes if you do not refund, that refunding pays off on charges up to roughly your dispute fee, and that it is likely not worth it on charges more than 35% above it. With a $15 fee that line sits near $20.
Cash-up: one month of 200 orders
A worked example, not a benchmark: 200 orders of $40 on Stripe's standard rates. Ten come from cards issued abroad in another currency, four are refunded in full, and one is disputed, fought and lost.
| Line | Working | Amount |
|---|---|---|
| Sales | 200 x $40.00 | $8,000.00 |
| Fees, US cards | 190 x $1.46 | $277.40 |
| Fees, cards from abroad | 10 x $2.46 | $24.60 |
| Fees kept on 4 refunds | 4 x $1.46, already in the lines above | $0.00 extra |
| Dispute fees | $15 received + $15 countered, lost | $30.00 |
| Card costs for the month | $277.40 + $24.60 + $30.00 | $332.00 (4.15%) |
The headline rate is 2.9%; the month cost 4.15% of sales. The $160 handed back on refunds and the $40 lost to the dispute come on top, as they would with cash, and the four refunded orders still paid $5.84 in fees for sales that no longer exist.
Six ways to keep more of each order
Make small orders bigger. Every payment pays the 30 cents. Two $10 items bought in one order pay $0.88 on Stripe; bought as two orders they pay $1.18. A minimum order value or a bundle does the same job.
Take bank payments on large invoices. Stripe's ACH Direct Debit costs 0.8% with a $5.00 cap, so a $1,200 invoice costs $5.00 instead of $35.10 by card. Square invoices paid by ACH cost 1% with a $1 minimum, capped at $10 on Plus and Premium; the Free plan has no cap.
Do the Square plan sum. A paid plan cuts the online rate by 0.4 points. Each $10 of monthly plan price is earned back at $2,500 of online card sales a month. Below that, the Free plan is cheaper for online payments, whatever else the plan brings.
Price in the currency you are paid out in. Stripe's extra 1% applies when a currency conversion is required. If the charge currency differs from the card currency, the customer's own bank may charge them a foreign exchange fee instead, so say clearly what currency your prices are in.
Cancel instead of refunding when you can. Taking payment at dispatch rather than at order means an order cancelled before then costs nothing, where a refund keeps the fee.
Head off disputes before they are filed. Card banks often ask about a charge first because the customer does not recognise it on their statement. Answering at that inquiry stage can settle it without a dispute fee. Make the name on the statement match the name on your website.
Questions about card fees on a website
Is the fee charged on sales tax and shipping too?
Yes. The percentage is taken from the whole amount charged, so a $40 order with $6 of shipping pays its fee on $46.
Does a debit card cost less than a credit card?
Not on these flat rates. Stripe's standard rate covers US credit, debit and prepaid cards and wallets alike, and Square's online rate applies to card payments of every kind.
When does a flat rate stop being the best deal?
At higher volume. Stripe offers custom pricing, including interchange plus, for businesses with large payment volume, and Square says businesses processing over $250,000 a year can ask for custom pricing.
Do I get the dispute fee back if the customer withdraws?
On Stripe in the US, no: the $15 dispute received fee is kept in every case unless your contract says otherwise. Only the $15 countered fee comes back, and only when you win.
Sources
- Stripe: Pricing and fees, US page, read 2026-11-12.
- Stripe Support: June 2025 pricing updates for disputes (US: $15 received, $15 countered) and Understanding fees for refunded payments.
- Stripe Docs: How disputes work, Refund and cancel payments and Currency conversions.
- Square: Understanding our fees, US page, read 2026-11-12, and Square Support: Process refunds.



